Capital Decisionby Anastasios Zervas
The Capital Decision · Agents · Negotiation

Before the seller cuts the price.


An $18,000 reduction and an $18,000 credit cost the seller the same. They do very different things for the buyer.

Illustrative scenario. People are composites and details are changed. Rates are examples, not quotes.

A home listed at $900,000 had been on the market long enough for the sellers to start talking about a reduction. Their agent suggested $18,000. A buyer was interested but stretched: at the market rate the payment was more than they wanted to carry.

The reduction would have helped less than anyone expected.

The same $18,000, two ways

Payment with no concession$4,912
Price reduced by $18,000: payment at 7.250%$4,813
Price reduced by $18,000: monthly saving$98
Seller credit toward the rate: rate after buydown6.625%
Seller credit toward the rate: payment$4,610
Seller credit toward the rate: monthly saving$301

Taken off the price, $18,000 lowers the loan by $14,400 and the payment by $98 a month. Offered instead as a credit toward the buyer’s rate, the same money lowers the payment by roughly three times as much.

The seller nets the same amount either way. The listing keeps its price, which matters for the next appraisal on the block. And the buyer gets the thing they were actually short of: monthly affordability.

Where the credit loses

  • If the buyer sells or refinances within a few years, part of the buydown’s value is never used. A price cut keeps its value for as long as the buyer owns the home.
  • A price cut also reduces the down payment and, in many places, transfer and property taxes.
  • Loan programs cap seller credits, commonly at 3% to 6% of the price for a primary residence depending on down payment.

A price reduction is the most visible concession. It is rarely the most efficient one.

The lesson

Price, credits and rate are three levers on the same deal. An agent who can explain the trade-offs has more to negotiate with than one who can only move the price. The numbers for a specific buyer come from that buyer’s lender.

For illustration and educational purposes only. This is not an offer or a mortgage offer and not advice for your situation. What any borrower qualifies for is determined by a lender after a full review.