Capital Decisionby Anastasios Zervas
The Capital Decision series

Scenarios where the obvious answer was not the best one


Each walks through a situation, the numbers behind it and the trade-offs on both sides.

Illustrative composites. The people are invented and details are changed. Figures are examples to show how a decision works, not terms offered by any lender or results anyone should expect.
Investors · Non-QM

Declined on his tax return. Approved on the property.

An investor with four profitable rentals could not qualify for a fifth. The problem was the question being asked.

Read the scenario →
Self-employed · Non-QM

The tax return said $68,000. The business said otherwise.

A contractor’s return showed what was taxable. His bank statements showed what he could afford.

Read the scenario →
Business owners · Non-QM

Her best year was the one no tax return showed yet.

A growing practice, two old returns and a house she could afford today.

Read the scenario →
Retirees · Non-QM

Two million in savings and no income to speak of.

A retired couple could have paid cash. They preferred not to, and the formula had no box for that.

Read the scenario →
Agents · Negotiation

Before the seller cuts the price.

An $18,000 reduction and an $18,000 credit cost the seller the same. They do very different things for the buyer.

Read the scenario →
Homeowners · Bridge

When life forces a move.

A 2.875% mortgage, a new job across the river and a market that punishes contingent offers.

Read the scenario →
Homeowners · Business owners

The locked asset.

Equity behind a 3.25% mortgage looks unreachable when the only tool considered is a refinance.

Read the scenario →
Homeowners · Refinance

A lower rate is not always a reason to refinance.

Half a point lower, $279 a month saved, and still the wrong decision for a three-year horizon.

Read the scenario →
Homeowners · Strategy

Pay a 30-year mortgage like a 15.

Most of the benefit of the shorter loan, with one option the shorter loan does not have.

Read the scenario →
Buyers · Business owners

The 20% down rule, examined.

Avoiding mortgage insurance is a good reason to put 20% down. It is not always a good enough one.

Read the scenario →
Buyers · Strategy

Renting versus owning, compared honestly.

The answer is not a philosophy. It is a number that depends mostly on how long you stay.

Read the scenario →
Buyers · Agents

Waiting for rates to fall.

Waiting is a decision with its own costs, and it needs two things to go right.

Read the scenario →
Buyers · Agents

FHA or conventional: the cheaper payment is not always the cheaper loan.

A first-time buyer with 5% down and two offers that look alike.

Read the scenario →
Life events · Attorneys

Keeping the house after a divorce.

The agreement gave her the home. Whether she could keep it was a separate question.

Read the scenario →
Retirees · Later life

House-rich in retirement.

A paid-down home, a tight monthly budget and a decision the whole family should understand.

Read the scenario →
Buyers · Agents

Buying the house that needs work.

The listing sat for 90 days because of its kitchen and roof. The financing was the missing piece.

Read the scenario →