Capital Decisionby Anastasios Zervas
The Capital Decision · Buyers · Agents

FHA or conventional: the cheaper payment is not always the cheaper loan.


A first-time buyer with 5% down and two offers that look alike.

Illustrative scenario. People are composites and details are changed. Rates are examples, not quotes.

A first-time buyer with 5% down on a $500,000 home and a mid-range credit score had two options in front of her. The FHA loan showed the lower rate and the lower payment. It looked like the obvious choice.

Conventional: loan amount$475,000
Conventional: total$3,437
FHA: upfront premium (1.75%), financed$8,313
FHA: loan with premium$483,313
FHA: total$3,253

On the monthly figures, FHA wins by $184. Three things do not show up in that number.

What the payment hides

  • The upfront premium. FHA adds $8,313 to her loan balance on day one.
  • Duration. With less than 10% down, FHA’s annual premium lasts for the life of the loan. Conventional insurance comes off once the loan reaches 80% of the home’s value.
  • The exit. Removing FHA insurance generally means refinancing, at whatever rates exist then, with new closing costs.

How she decided

She expected her income to rise and planned to stay at least seven years. Conventional insurance at her score was expensive now and would fall away later. FHA was cheaper now and permanent unless she refinanced. She worked out how long it would take to reach 80% and compared the totals over that period.

The cheaper payment and the cheaper loan are sometimes two different loans.

The lesson

With stronger credit, conventional usually wins outright. With weaker credit and little down, FHA often does. In the middle, the answer depends on time, and on whether a later refinance is a plan or a hope.

For illustration and educational purposes only. This is not an offer or a mortgage offer and not advice for your situation. What any borrower qualifies for is determined by a lender after a full review.