Illustrative scenario. People are composites and details are changed. Rates are examples, not quotes.
“Always put 20% down” is sound advice with one purpose: avoiding mortgage insurance. It says nothing about what else the money could do.
A buyer of a $700,000 home had $140,000 saved, exactly 20%. She also owned a small business with uneven cash flow and no other reserves.
Ten percent against twenty
Putting 10% down costs $690 more a month, part of it mortgage insurance that can later be removed. It leaves $70,000 in her account.
What the cash is for
Earning interest on it recovers only part of the extra payment. That is not the point. For someone whose income varies, $70,000 of reserves is the difference between riding out a slow quarter and borrowing on a credit card at three times the mortgage rate. For someone with stable income and other savings, the same analysis favors 20% down.
The down payment decision is a liquidity decision that happens to be made at a closing table.
The lesson
Mortgage insurance is a cost with an end date. Illiquidity is a risk without one. The rule of thumb is a good default and a poor substitute for looking at the whole balance sheet.