Capital Decisionby Anastasios Zervas
The Capital Decision · Homeowners · Refinance

A lower rate is not always a reason to refinance.


Half a point lower, $279 a month saved, and still the wrong decision for a three-year horizon.

Illustrative scenario. People are composites and details are changed. Rates are examples, not quotes.

A homeowner with $500,000 at 7.00% and 27 years remaining was offered 6.50% on a new 30-year loan. The payment would fall by $279 a month. Closing costs were $11,000. He expected to move in about three years.

The simple test and the complete one

Simple break-even on closing costs3 years, 4 months
Payments saved$10,034
Extra balance owed on the new loan$2,946
Net benefit after costs and balance difference-$3,912

The simple break-even, costs divided by monthly savings, is 3 years, 4 months. That alone is longer than he planned to stay.

The complete test is less forgiving. Part of the lower payment comes from stretching 27 years back to 30. After three years he would owe $2,946 more on the new loan than on the old one. Counting payments saved, costs paid and that extra balance, the refinance leaves him $3,912 behind.

What would change the answer

  • A longer horizon. At six or seven years the same refinance comes out ahead.
  • Lower costs, or a slightly higher rate with the costs covered by the lender.
  • A shorter new term, so the saving comes from the rate and not from the reset.

A lower payment and a saving are not the same thing.

The lesson

Refinancing is a purchase. The price is the closing costs and the reset of the term; the product is a lower rate for as long as the loan lasts. It is worth buying only if it will be used long enough.

For illustration and educational purposes only. This is not an offer or a mortgage offer and not advice for your situation. What any borrower qualifies for is determined by a lender after a full review.