Illustrative scenario. People are composites and details are changed. Rates are examples, not quotes.
A couple choosing between a 30-year and a 15-year mortgage on $500,000 liked the idea of being debt-free sooner. The 15-year loan offered a lower rate. It also came with a required payment about $1,000 higher, every month, with no exceptions.
One of them is self-employed.
A third option
They took the 30-year loan and paid it on a 15-year schedule.
The required payment is $3,243. Paying $4,425 retires the loan in 15 years and saves $370,985 in interest. A true 15-year loan at a lower rate would cost a little less each month, $4,246.
What the difference buys
The gap between the two is the price of an option: in a slow quarter, after a job change or during an emergency, they can drop back to the required payment without asking anyone’s permission. With the 15-year loan, a hard month is a missed payment.
The discipline is theirs to supply. A plan to pay extra that is abandoned after a year delivers none of the benefit. Some people are better served by the loan that forces the outcome.
The 15-year loan is cheaper. The 30-year loan paid like a 15 is safer. Which matters more depends on how steady the income is.