Illustrative scenario. People are composites and details are changed. Rates are examples, not quotes.
George and Maria retired with about $2,200,000 in savings and investments, Social Security, and a plan to move closer to their grandchildren. The home they chose cost $1,100,000. They could have paid cash.
They did not want to. Selling that much from taxable accounts in one year would have created a large tax bill and left them with less invested than they were comfortable with. They preferred to put about a third down and finance the rest.
Their income, on paper, was $3,500 a month.
Counting what they owned
An asset depletion calculation discounted their accounts by type, subtracted the funds they would use to close, and spread the remainder over 84 months.
The result, $20,524 a month, exists only for underwriting. No withdrawals were required and no accounts were pledged.
What they compared
- Paying cash, with the tax cost of liquidating.
- Financing under a standard program using documented retirement distributions, which would have required setting up withdrawals they did not need.
- Financing with asset depletion at a somewhat higher rate.
Their advisor and accountant ran the tax side. The mortgage was one input into a larger decision about which assets to hold and which to spend.
They had the means. What they lacked was a line on a form.
The lesson
For households living on assets, the loan decision and the portfolio decision are the same decision. It belongs in a room with the advisor and the CPA.