Illustrative scenario. People are composites and details are changed. Rates are examples, not quotes.
A business owner had $400,000 left on a mortgage at 3.25% and a home worth well over a million dollars. She needed $150,000 for an expansion. Everyone she asked told her the same thing: with rates where they were, her equity was locked up. Refinancing would mean giving up 3.25%.
They were right about the refinance and wrong about the equity.
Two ways to borrow $150,000
A cash-out refinance reprices all $550,000 at today’s rate in order to borrow $150,000 of it. Keeping the first mortgage and adding a second lien applies the higher rate only to the new money. The blended rate across both loans is 4.68%.
What the second lien asks in return
- A HELOC’s rate is variable. The blended rate is a snapshot, not a promise.
- The interest-only draw period ends, and the payment rises when it does.
- A fixed-rate home equity loan removes both risks at a somewhat higher starting cost.
The asset was never locked. Only one door to it was.
The lesson
A low-rate first mortgage is itself an asset. The question is not whether to use home equity but which structure preserves the most of what is already in place.